PURCHASES MADE THROUGH THE LINKS BELOW MAY EARN US AND OUR PUBLISHING PARTNERS A COMMISSION.
As the demand for healthier cookware continues to rise, non-toxic pans have become a popular choice for those seeking safer alternatives in the kitchen. In this comprehensive review, we will evaluate and compare the features, performance, and overall quality of non-toxic pans from four renowned brands: Our Place, Caraway Home, Made In, and All-Clad.
Our Place
Design and Aesthetic:
Our Place has earned a reputation not only for its functionality but also for its aesthetic appeal. The Always Pan, one of their flagship products, boasts a sleek design with a variety of color options, making it a stylish addition to any kitchen. The multi-functional aspect of the pan adds to its appeal, making it versatile for different cooking styles and techniques.
Material and Construction:
Our Place pans are crafted from high-quality materials, featuring a non-toxic ceramic coating free from harmful chemicals like PFOA and PTFE. The pan’s interior is non-stick, providing an easy cooking experience without the need for excessive oil or butter. The sturdy construction includes an aluminum body for efficient heat distribution.
Performance:
The Always Pan excels in versatility, allowing users to steam, fry, boil, and sauté with a single pan. The non-stick coating performs admirably, and the pan is easy to clean, either by hand or in the dishwasher. The even heat distribution ensures consistent cooking results.
Durability:
Our Place pans are generally durable, requiring proper care to maintain longevity. Some users have reported wear and tear on the non-stick coating over time, emphasizing the importance of following care instructions provided by the manufacturer.
Caraway Home:
Design and Aesthetic:
Caraway Home pans are known for their minimalist design and muted color palette. The brand emphasizes simplicity and functionality in its cookware. The ceramic coating is free from harmful chemicals, making it a safe choice for health-conscious consumers. The Caraway Home pan design is geared towards easy storage with a vertical storage option, utilizing a magnetic pan rack.
Material and Construction:
Similar to Our Place, Caraway Home pans are constructed with non-toxic ceramic coatings. The pans feature an aluminum core for efficient heat distribution, ensuring that your food cooks evenly. The construction is robust, and the pans are suitable for various cooking methods.
Performance:
Caraway Home pans offer reliable non-stick performance, making cooking and cleaning hassle-free. The even heat distribution allows for precise temperature control, catering to different culinary needs. Users appreciate the versatility of these pans, suitable for a wide range of dishes.
Durability:
Caraway Home pans are generally durable, and their lifespan can be influenced by factors such as usage and maintenance. Proper care, including avoiding the use of metal utensils and following cleaning guidelines, contributes to the longevity of the non-stick coating.
| Our Place | Caraway | |
|---|---|---|
| Product Offerings | Two cookware offerings: Ceramic non-stick and enameled cast iron | Only one cookware offering: Ceramic non-stick |
| Base Construction | Aluminum or cast iron | Aluminum |
| Cooking Surface | Ceramic non-stick or enameled cast iron | Ceramic non-stick |
| Oven-Safe Temperature | Always Pan 2.0 is safe up to 450°F; enameled cast iron cookware is safe up to 500°F without the lid | Up to 550°F |
| Induction-Compatible | All cookware is induction-compatible | All cookware is induction-compatible |
| Color Options | 9 colors | 13 colors |
| Riveted Handles | No | Yes |
| Handle Design | Squared | Rounded |
| Where It’s Made | Made in China, Thailand, and Mexico | Made in China |
| Company History | Founded in 2019 | Founded in 2018 |
| Price | $$-$$$ (FromOurPlace.com) | $$$ (CarawayHome.com) |
| Main Benefit | Comes with a steamer basket and wooden spoon; rivetless handles | Colorful exterior; oven-safe up to 550°F; less expensive |
| Main Downside | Not oven-safe; expensive; non-stick coating wears down quickly | Exterior coating flakes off; non-stick coating wears down quickly |
Made In:
Design and Aesthetic:
Made In pans are celebrated for their sleek and modern design, incorporating both functionality and elegance. The brand offers a variety of styles and finishes, catering to different aesthetic preferences. The minimalist approach of Made In pans is coupled with a focus on performance.
Material and Construction:
Made In pans boast a combination of non-toxic ceramic coatings and stainless steel, ensuring durability and even heat distribution. The pans feature a multi-layer construction for enhanced performance and are compatible with various cooking surfaces.
Performance:
Made In pans are designed for professional-level performance, delivering precise temperature control and exceptional non-stick capabilities. Users appreciate the durability and versatility of these pans, making them suitable for a range of cooking techniques.
Durability:
Made In pans are known for their durability, with proper care contributing significantly to their lifespan. The stainless steel construction and high-quality coatings make them resistant to wear and tear, offering a reliable and long-lasting cooking experience.
All-Clad:
Design and Aesthetic:
All-Clad pans are recognized for their classic and timeless design. The brand focuses on a professional aesthetic, with stainless steel exteriors and ergonomic handles. While not as colorful as some other brands, All-Clad pans exude a sense of culinary sophistication.
Material and Construction:
All-Clad pans are constructed with premium materials, including stainless steel and aluminum. This combination ensures excellent heat distribution and durability. The brand’s dedication to quality craftsmanship is evident in the meticulous construction of their pans.
Performance:
All-Clad pans are renowned for their exceptional performance in terms of heat control and even cooking. The stainless steel interior provides a non-reactive surface, ideal for various cooking methods. Users often praise the consistent results achieved with All-Clad pans.
Durability:
All-Clad pans are built to last, with a reputation for durability. The high-quality materials and craftsmanship contribute to their longevity, and with proper care, these pans can withstand the rigors of regular cooking.
Comparison:
1. Design:
- Our Place: Bold and stylish with a variety of colors.
- Caraway Home: Minimalist and functional with a focus on easy storage.
- Made In: Sleek and modern, offering a variety of styles.
- All-Clad: Classic and timeless with a professional aesthetic.
2. Material and Construction:
- All four brands use non-toxic ceramic coatings and combinations of stainless steel and aluminum for efficient heat distribution.
3. Performance:
- All brands offer reliable non-stick performance and even heat distribution, catering to different cooking needs.
4. Durability:
- Durability is influenced by proper care, and all brands require attention to maintenance guidelines. Each brand has a reputation for producing durable cookware.
Our Pick:
Our Place
With its bold designs, non-stick ceramic coating, and multi-use functionality our editors have chosen the Our Place Always Pan 2.0 as our favorite Non-Toxic Cookware. The 10.5-inch pan can braise, sear, steam, strain, saute, frie, boil, bake, serve, and store is why we love it. Plus it can be used in the oven up to 450°F. Check out the Always Pan 2.0 now and get a 100-day free trial!
